When I speak with couples about their estate planning many honestly believe their kids and their family will handle the end of their life respectfully because they all get along now. However, long experience demonstrates that parents do not consider the effect of a significant stressful event in the complex tangle of family emotions and relationships.
The death or serious illness of a loved one introduces a significant change that alters the balance of power and balance of interests. You cannot anticipate how the balances will shift. The child or loved one that has always done what you wanted during life will suddenly rationalize why they should do something other than follow your wishes.
Please don't be naive and believe it only happens to others. It can happen to you as easily as it happens to others.
In this article in the Wall Street Journal (pointed out by Professor Beyer) the author reviews her family's experience when her mother executed a health care power of attorney, also known as a health care proxy or health care directive before she went for serious surgery.
What follows next is just a portion of her experience that demonstrates the very strong emotions and reactions that follow important decisions regarding appointment of a health care power of attorney or proxy.
I thought mom's logic made sense: Bob has been her companion of almost 20 years -- though not married, they might as well be. And since her oldest son, my brother Mike, lives in Texas, Mom chose her second-oldest (me) to be her second proxy. (What mother wants her child agonizing over making life or death decisions from halfway across the country?)
But Melissa didn't see it that way. As the youngest child, Melissa has always been especially close with our mom and she felt strongly that she knew mom's wishes best. Melissa felt she should be the one to make decisions when it came to anything as serious as end-of-life care for our mother.
Obviously, the mother made her choice based upon her important factors and values. But, her daughter Melissa thought other factors and values should have applied, creating the conflict. This conflict hadn't appeared before in the complex family relationship, simply because it had never been raised in the family before.
No one knows the complex emotions that are below the surface in our loved ones. Consequently, if appropriate you can share your decisions and address the complex emotions before the time of crisis.